From ‘I Want to Go to a Better World with You’ to ‘You Are No Longer Good Enough for Me’ – An Anatomy of Human Nature
Publication Date: 14 April 2026
Latest Update Date: 14 April 2026
Author: Ailven LIU 刘翔
All Rights Reserved
True love says: I have seen a better world, and I want to go there with you.
False love says: I have seen a better world; you are no longer good enough for me, so do not hold me back.
The difference between these two statements looks like a difference in temperature. It is in fact the difference between two utterly distinct philosophies of human relationship – more precisely, between two utterly distinct understandings of what a human being is.
The former acknowledges the symbiotic nature of a relationship; it acknowledges that love entails walking together, supporting one another, waiting, and making room for each other’s incompleteness. The latter treats a relationship as a provisional arrangement, and treats a person as an asset that may appreciate or depreciate in value. The moment a better platform, a superior path, or a more advantageous future appears, the old relationship is instantly demoted from a ‘community of destiny’ to a ‘historical burden’. The former still treats a person as a person. The latter has already reduced a person to a tool; it merely wraps that instrumental rationality in a layer of refined language, mature rhetoric, composure, and an air of seeming transcendence over vulgar reality.
Thus, when many people part, abandon, betray, or turn their faces away, they speak of growth while calculating returns. They speak of incompatibility while thinking that you are no longer worth the cost. What they mean by wishing each other well is: do not delay my ascent.
People change; that much is unremarkable. The question is whether the change moves them towards truthfulness, or towards a greater skill in finding respectable narratives for selfishness.
I. The truth of love is not, first of all, an emotional question, but a question of how one regards the Other
Every intimate relationship, in the final analysis, cannot avoid one most brutal question: what exactly do you take the other person to be?
This is a more fundamental question than ‘Do you love me?’ because the word love is far too easily abused. It may mean desire, dependence, possession, illusion, projection, or a form of self-intoxication that has not yet been tested by reality. Many people claim to love someone deeply, when in fact what they love is the version of themselves reflected beside that person: admired, affirmed, needed, and made radiant.
Martin Buber distinguished between the ‘I–Thou’ relation and the ‘I–It’ relation. The former regards the other as an irreplaceable being; the latter regards the other as an object, a resource, a tool, a means. One of the tragedies of human life is that many intimate relationships begin in the language of ‘I–Thou’, yet, at decisive moments, reveal themselves to be thoroughly structured by ‘I–It’.
When all is going well, the other is a soulmate, the only one, destiny, a spiritual companion; but the moment interests, prospects, status, class mobility, living costs, external judgement, and opportunities for upward movement begin to intervene, the way many people treat a partner suddenly becomes as rational as the way a firm handles an underperforming asset: assessment, comparison, weighing, depreciation, divestment, disposal.
This does not mean that they were lying from the beginning. The more frightening truth is that they may indeed once have been sincere – moved, attached, invested. Yet that sincerity was never unconditional. It existed only so long as you continued to satisfy their expectations; once you no longer met that hidden and severe function of value, what had been called devotion swiftly withdrew its capital.
This is the first truth of love: many relationships rest upon a provisional recognition of the value a person appears to carry. The person as such is never the foundation.
II. The thing at which modern society excels most is turning every relationship into a transaction
If ancient society arranged relationships more directly through lineage, clan order, property, and marriage hierarchy, modern society is cleverer, and colder. It no longer crudely commands you whom you must marry or must remain with. Instead, through education, media, professional life, urban stratification, consumerism, and the omnipresent machinery of competition, it continuously instils an almost irresistible standard of judgement:
Who has the brighter future is more deserving of investment;
Who grows faster is more worthy of love;
Who occupies the higher platform has the greater right to eliminate others.
And whoever stays where they are has earned being left behind.
Thus, love – the very relationship that ought most to resist the invasion of utility – becomes one of the easiest sites for social discipline to penetrate. Two people appear to be in love, while in fact they are jointly participating in a covert process of valuation. The degree to which a person is loved increasingly depends on whether he or she can provide a respectable life, a trajectory of growth, emotional utility, social gain, class aspiration, and a sense of future security. What is called ‘compatibility’ often means little more than ‘the ratio of returns to costs remains acceptable’; what is called ‘having no future together’ often means nothing more than ‘your valuation no longer looks promising’.
Hegel pointed out that self-consciousness depends upon recognition. Yet modern society has rendered recognition extraordinarily mercenary: it recognises only your performance, your potential, your visibility, and your capacity for upward mobility. Thus, what many people suffer in intimate relationships is a sentence rather different from ‘I no longer love you as a person’: ‘Given your present configuration, you are no longer worth my continued investment.’
This is why many separations produce a humiliation almost ontological in its force. What truly pierces is less the loss of one concrete individual than the judgement implied by that person’s departure: you are not enough, you are not worth it, you have fallen behind, you have no right to enter the future I wish to inhabit.
Modern intimate relationships are so cruel precisely because they inherit the core logic of the market: everything can be compared, everything must justify its rate of return, and everything that cannot continue to appreciate ought to be replaced.
III. What is called ‘mature lucidity’ is very often merely refined egoism in its civilised dress
What deserves vigilance today is not naked selfishness, but selfishness that has been exquisitely civilised.
The truly crude person is not the most dangerous, for greed, contempt, opportunism, and the will to exploit are almost written on his face. What is dangerous is the person of cultivated language, rigorous logic, polished taste, respectable bearing, and perhaps even a slight philosophical air. Such people do not say, ‘You are no longer of use to me, so I do not want you any more.’ They say, ‘What I seek is a higher dimension of growth.’ Where a plainer speaker would say ‘you are beneath me’, they say, ‘Our levels of cognition are no longer on the same plane.’ A demand for a stronger provider becomes a wish for someone who can truly stand alongside them; the complaint that you are weighing them down becomes the declaration that they must remain faithful to the rhythm of their own life.
The most insidious thing about this rhetoric is that it disguises selfishness as self-respect, utility as lucidity, betrayal as growth, abandonment as responsibility towards the future.
Sartre called this bad faith. Human beings cannot bear to see themselves as merely vulgar creatures of profit, calculation, snobbery, and submission to advantage, and so they manufacture a noble narrative for their own conduct. In this way, they may enjoy real benefit while escaping the ugliness of moral self-knowledge. More than that, they may come sincerely to believe that they are pursuing a better self, respecting the selection of fate, enacting the evolution of life itself.
Such people are often especially adept at one thing: when no conflict of interest exists, they appear intensely idealistic; once core interests are touched, they switch instantly to the most thoroughgoing instrumental rationality. One moment they are speaking of tenderness, soul, romance, meaning, and mutual growth; the next they are calculating marginal returns, opportunity costs, future yield, emotional burden, and the timing of exit. More disgusting still, they beautify this switch under the name of ‘maturity’.
What is called ‘maturity’, in this context, means learning at last to bear no costs for others and to be responsible only for oneself; learning to withdraw affection at the proper moment, lest an inefficient relationship continue to erode one’s path of ascent; learning to subsume all feeling under the logic of cost-benefit analysis.
This ‘maturity’ is not growth, but the marketisation of personality.
IV. Later circumstances reveal a structure that was always there
People like to say: ‘He changed.’ ‘She was not like this before.’
Most of the time, this is only half true.
A more accurate formulation would be: at certain stages, a person’s underlying structure has not yet been fully activated; when new resources, opportunities, status, choices, and avenues of mobility appear, that concealed structure finally acquires room to unfold.
A person who is weak, dependent, unseen, and not yet seated at the table may appear extremely gentle, loyal, affectionate, humble, and grateful. For at that stage, he needs connection, support, you, the relationship, the stability it offers, the emotional comfort it provides, perhaps even the resources by which it lifts him. His sincerity at that stage is real enough, but it remains contingent upon the ongoing usefulness of the relationship to himself.
Once circumstances change – educational elevation, professional elevation, rising income, a renewed social circle, a swollen self-estimation, rapidly expanding options – his understanding of the relationship may alter at once. What was previously received as warmth begins to seem cumbersome; what had once been taken as a shared future comes to feel like a constraint. Then old covenants are reinterpreted, old attachments renamed, old investments revalued.
The most typical gesture is the revision of history.
He will say that he was simply young and unknowing;
That it was never love, only dependence;
That any two people could have replicated those sweet moments;
That you failed to grow.
This is a form of moral self-preservation, and it is more than a correction of memory. Unless the past, the other person, and the relationship’s former reality are all diminished, he would have to admit that his departure now contains betrayal, calculation, and a reorientation of value. To avoid facing that, the easiest course is to degrade the past itself: if it was never truly lofty, then casting it aside need incur no guilt.
Thus, many people have not suddenly grown heartless. They have merely reached the point at which they no longer need your existence in order to stabilise their own. When they can independently obtain confirmation from a higher order of reality, you are transformed from ‘the person of destiny’ into a ‘stage-specific arrangement’.
V. What wounds most is never departure itself, but the humiliation of value that departs with it
Departure is not necessarily cruel. Human intentions change, emotions fade, relationships break apart: this is part of reality. What often leaves people unable to recover for years is less the fact of the leaving than the verdict attached to it: ‘before leaving, you proved me inferior’.
Many people, when ending a relationship, are not content merely to exit; they also require the moral high ground. They wish to go, and to have you believe that the fault was yours: that your inadequacy explains the end, that you were always unworthy of the commitment you received, that you failed to grow into someone worth retaining.
Thus separation ceases to be the termination of a relationship and becomes a public or private trial of value. What one suffers is not merely the end of the relationship. It is a liquidation of personality.
This humiliation is so effective because it strikes at one of humanity’s deepest fears: not being chosen, not being needed, not being regarded as a person of worth. In intimacy, that fear is amplified to the utmost. For the denial of a stranger remains a social judgement; the denial of one who was closest is easily mistaken for existential truth. One instinctively thinks: if even the person nearest to me saw me this way, then perhaps I truly am unworthy.
Many people’s later collapse is, on the surface, caused by heartbreak; in fact it is caused by the loss of narrative authority. They no longer possess the right to interpret that relationship, nor the right to testify to their own value. The whole rhetorical edifice left behind by the departing person – you are childish, low, burdensome, suffocating, inadequate, unworthy – remains within the soul like a judicial sentence, furnishing the grounds for a new round of self-condemnation.
And this is precisely one of the most sinister aspects of modern relationships: one party leaves, and the other loses the relationship, and with it the right to bear witness on his or her own behalf.
VI. The phrase ‘I merely want a better life’ often means: ‘I am prepared to sacrifice others in exchange for it’
A sentence must be spoken here that many people do not wish to hear: the so-called pursuit of ‘a better life’ is, in most cases, not a pure proposition at all.
For ‘better’ is not itself guilty. The question is what cost one is prepared to pay for this ‘better’, and which costs one is prepared to shift on to others.
If someone says: I have seen bigger cities, better education, higher platforms, a wider world, and therefore I hope that we may strive together, increase together, and bear together the cost of migration and reconstruction – then this is a joint ascent, an ethic of partnership, the treatment of the relationship as a common enterprise.
But if someone says: I have seen a larger world, and therefore I realise that you are no longer good enough, that you cannot keep up, that you must not cling to me, that you must not delay my pace – then there is nothing noble here. There is only the plainest, oldest, and commonest feature of human nature: when I possess a better option, I shall immediately reprice you.
Nietzsche spoke of the ‘revaluation of values’, yet most real-world revaluation creates no higher value; it is only a more efficient submission to the logic of strength. Once a person senses that he has more capital, all the defects of the other which he could once tolerate are swiftly upgraded into unacceptable structural flaws. Once it was ‘we can change together’; later it becomes ‘I do not wish to go through change with you’. Once it was ‘we shall go together’; later it becomes ‘do not obstruct my going’.
Observe that the change in ethical stance is what matters here, and the gap in capability is not. A true community does not require two people always to grow at the same speed; but it does at least require that the stronger party, before all hope is exhausted, not treat the weaker as a lagging component to be discarded. Modern cruelty lies precisely here: people admit without shame that they do not wish to wait, and wrap the unwillingness in the language of ‘I need not wrong myself’.
In one sentence: what many people call their ideal life is nothing more than a permit that legitimises the abandonment of lower-value former relationships.
VII. Love is scarce because people need it to prove their own success
Modern people are famished for intimacy, more so than ever: to be understood, accompanied, and seen. The problem is that they increasingly struggle to allow love to remain love. They demand that it perform additional functions.
Love must prove that one is worth envying;
Love must prove that one has not chosen badly;
Love must become a combined certificate of social display, class ascent, spiritual superiority, and existential correctness.
Thus, a partner ceases to be merely a partner, and becomes part of one’s curriculum vitae, part of one’s identity, part of one’s imagined future. To be chosen now means demonstrating: my life has turned out rather well. Conversely, to be abandoned is no longer merely an emotional defeat; it is often experienced as a social devaluation.
In such a situation, love must inevitably be corrupted. For once love is made to bear the burden of proving one’s value, it can never truly be unconditional. You may accompany me through hardship, provided that hardship still leads to a better future; you may be lost, provided that your confusion does not reduce the valuation of my own life.
The moment these premises are doubted, what is called feeling changes at once. Their attachment has always been tied to a larger enterprise: through the relationship with you, they seek confirmation of their own correctness.
Erich Fromm wrote that love is a capacity, not an emotion. Yet modern society is more inclined to treat love as a prize: the more excellent one is, the more entitled one is to it; the brighter one’s future, the more deserving one is of long-term investment. In such an environment, anyone still capable of treating the other as an end rather than a means must be rare indeed. For this requires a person partially to withdraw from the entire social system of valuation, or at least to preserve within intimacy a territory not wholly governed by performance. Most people cannot do it, and the reason is not a lack of intelligence. They are unwilling to bear the risk.
They would sooner lose love than lose the chance of winning.
VIII. The most widespread feature of human nature is conditional benevolence
If all this were reduced merely to ‘wickedness’, the matter would become too simple. The truly terrible thing about human nature is something much commoner than great evil: benevolence that lasts only so long as one remains safe, comfortable, and unthreatened; once core interests are involved, benevolence evaporates at once.
This is not unique to modern society. Countless struggles for power, marriage alliances, calculations of rank, literary circles, court factions, and commercial partnerships throughout history repeatedly demonstrate the same truth: human kindness towards others is often founded upon the condition that no serious sacrifice be demanded of oneself. The moment the price becomes too high, so-called loyalty yields to self-preservation.
Hobbes observed that competition, diffidence, and the pursuit of glory lie latent in the relation of man to man. Modern society has not abolished these things; it has merely wrapped them in more elegant forms. People today do not directly say, as they might once have done, ‘our families are not of equal standing’; instead they say, ‘our values do not align’. A plain ‘you have lost status’ becomes ‘I no longer feel we are on the same path’; a plain ‘I wish to climb a higher branch’ becomes ‘I must be responsible to my future’.
Civilisation has advanced, speech has grown elegant, methods gentler, yet the logic remains unchanged. One might even say that, because we have learnt more refined expressions, many cruelties have become harder to identify and harder still to condemn.
Thus the root of ‘false love’ lies less in the vice of a few rotten individuals than in one of the commonest and most worldly features of human nature: I may love you, provided I continue to believe that loving you will not cost me too much.
This is conditional benevolence. It is not monstrous in the melodramatic sense, yet it is sufficient to destroy many people’s most basic faith in life. For it arrives clothed as love, yet at the critical moment reveals something more injurious than hatred: precise calculation of value.
IX. True love takes reality into account without revoking recognition
One clarification is necessary: to criticise instrumentalised love is not to advocate some completely unreal romantic fantasy detached from the world.
True love obviously cannot deny material pressures, income disparity, relocation, professional prospects, emotional labour, or family responsibility. A truly mature relationship is certainly not the childish declaration that ‘love alone is enough’. That belongs to cheap fiction, not to life.
The key question is rather this: once reality enters the relationship, what role does it play?
In false love, reality becomes the reason for withdrawing recognition. You are not sufficiently excellent, and therefore I no longer regard you as someone worth bearing with or bearing for.
In true love, reality becomes a shared problem to be worked upon. The world has become harder, and therefore we must redivide labour, remould ourselves, and determine anew how not to relinquish each other.
The difference lies less in whether one is rational than in what that rationality serves. In the former case, reason serves self-preservation and valuation-maximisation. In the latter, reason is placed in the service of sustaining the common life. The former asks: ‘Is this relationship still worth it for me?’ The latter asks: ‘How may we continue, within reality, without abandoning one another?’
This is the fundamental distinction revealed in the opening contrast:
True love is, after seeing a greater world, still including the other person within the structure of one’s future;
False love is, after seeing a greater world, immediately updating the valuation of the other by a new standard, and then calling elimination ‘destiny’.
In other words, true love is fidelity. It refuses to revoke personhood on account of difference, and it refuses to treat growth as a licence to discard one’s companion.
X. Conclusion: what people most often betray is not another person, but their own former claim that ‘you are irreplaceable’
Among the cheapest sentences in human life is: ‘I shall always stay by your side.’
Among the costliest acts is this: once one has acquired a better option, still refusing to treat the person beside one as a residue of an earlier, lower version of oneself that ought to be cast off.
So what this essay really wishes to say is something more merciless than the observation that certain people are bad:
Most people possess no capacity for love; what they possess is the capacity, when conditions are favourable, to display a fervour resembling love.
Most people have not yet found sufficient reason to despise the person beside them, and mistake that for respect.
What passes for faithfulness is, in most cases, the absence of a higher-grade substitute.
What passes for honesty is the absence of pressure: reality has not yet forced them to display their calculations.
And what is called ‘refined egoism’ is almost the default personality template of modern society. It is not the vice of a few ambitious or clever people. At school people learn to compare; at work they learn to weigh; in social life they learn to display; in intimate relationships they learn to appraise. In the end, they no longer even feel that they are using others; they sincerely believe: I am merely lucid, I am merely growing, I am merely learning at last to love myself.
Unfortunately, the terminus of much so-called ‘self-love’ is simply the loss of the ability to love anyone else.
Thus the coldest scene in the world repeats itself again and again:
One person once held another’s hand and said, let us go to the future together;
Later he sees brighter lights, higher floors, a wider world, and lets go of that hand, saying lightly: you can no longer keep up.
Then he turns away and explains his betrayal as lucidity, his heartlessness as maturity, and his instinct for profit and self-preservation as the selection of fate.
This is the final form of false love:
a tenderness that always had a price;
a sincerity that never accepted loss;
a longing for a better world, indulged alone or with those deemed worthy enough to accompany it.
And true love is rare, though not because people cannot utter beautiful words.
In an age filled with valuation, competition, and universal upward striving,
to remain willing, after seeing the world clearly,
not first to take the world’s measuring rod and cut apart the person beside one –
that, in itself, has already become extraordinarily difficult.