Publication Date: 21 March 2026
Author: Ailven LIU 刘翔
All Rights Reserved
A Cold Self-Statement on Failure, Self-Defence, Value Camouflage, and Personality Split.
I am increasingly aware that what truly requires judgement is how I deploy such language to preserve a self-image that still refuses to collapse. My work, my income, my emotional history, and even the notion I profess – that ‘life is greater than utility’ – are secondary to that.
I. The Suspicion of ‘Life First’
I once found it plausible to believe that I belonged to a certain type of person: one not excessively attached to material gain, one who keeps a distance from utilitarian competition, one who regards leisure, reading, walking, music, urban wandering, purposeless observation and sensation as the true texture of life. This view is hardly rare; indeed, it carries a faint air of spiritual superiority. It allows one to believe that one has not been wholly trained by the world into a machine that merely calculates returns, compares gains and losses, and chases status and wealth. It permits one to think that even if one has not ‘won’ in the worldly sense, it does not follow that one has ‘lost’, because one has retained a higher faculty of judgement: the ability to recognise what truly matters.
The problem lies precisely here. Once a person begins to emphasise ‘what truly matters’, it often signals that he is already experiencing loss in those worldly domains that are visible, comparable, and quantifiable. The louder the proclamation of value, the more likely it arises from a precarious position in reality, and the less likely from deeper insight. The more a person insists that he does not care about something, the more one must suspect that it is exactly what he cannot calmly admit he cares about deeply.
Thus, looking back at myself today, I can no longer easily regard ‘life first’ as a naturally noble conviction. I must place it on the operating table and dissect it: is it truly my value, or merely an explanatory shell I have constructed after prolonged failure in order to prevent total collapse of the self?
I must first admit something I was previously unwilling to acknowledge: I do care about worldly competition. I envy salary increases, promotions, platform transitions; I envy those who have positioned themselves correctly within capital markets, industrial cycles, and upward career trajectories. I am provoked by the progress of my peers, stung by news of others’ wealth, and beneath an apparently calm surface, I carry a persistent and concrete sense of humiliation at my own stagnation. I remain within the market order and accept most of its judgements. My pain itself proves that I have never truly exited this evaluative system. If income, platform, prospects, and social position were genuinely irrelevant to me, I would not repeatedly compare inwardly; I would not experience that instinctive imbalance when hearing of others’ salary rises; I would not construct such cruel and humiliating comparisons between my own income and others’ tax statements.
In other words, I am merely someone who lacks the capacity to calmly say, ‘I also want to win.’ I seem more willing to interpret myself as someone who values life and dismisses utility, because that at least preserves a degree of personal dignity. To admit that I desire worldly success is to admit that I am not fundamentally different from those I once subtly disdained or tried to distance myself from. I compare, I calculate, I wish to validate myself through income, position, and external recognition. It is only because I have not achieved sufficiently good results in this competition that I require a discourse of greater ‘spiritual elevation’ to offset the embarrassment of this outcome.
This is precisely what renders ‘life first’ suspect. It is unlikely to be a primary belief; it reads as a secondary rhetoric, an interpretation imposed after unfavourable results rather than an original ordering of values. Its function is damage control, not judgement. It allows me to rewrite ‘I failed to obtain more’ as ‘those things were not that important anyway’; to rewrite ‘I lag behind in competition’ as ‘at least I still possess life’; to rewrite ‘the world has judged me insufficient’ as ‘I have not been alienated by the world’. These reinterpretations are not transparent. They frequently operate under the guise of philosophy while performing the task of psychological defence.
II. The Wound of Being Judged Unworthy
I must also admit that what my former partner said at the moment of separation has affected me far more deeply than I would like to acknowledge. It was a judgement laden with hierarchy: I am inferior, my horizon is limited, I cannot handle her, I am unworthy of her. The most devastating aspect was that she issued a valuation of my very existence in a language of social status, hierarchy, and capital. It was a fine, sharp blade inserted into the most vulnerable region of male self-esteem: capability, status, value, and worthiness. It forced me to confront an intolerable possibility: that intimacy is at times merely another concealed yet equally brutal mechanism of value selection.
After that, I could no longer regard income, platform, and prospects as purely professional matters. They became bound to a more humiliating question: am I worthy? Do I deserve to be chosen? Do I have the right to possess better relationships, better life conditions, greater space? My concern for salary, promotion, and success became a concern for the recognisability of my own value. Thus, the more I emphasise ‘life above utility’, the more likely it reflects the depth of the wound inflicted by utilitarian logic, and the less likely any transcendence of it. I am resisting that logic from within the wound.
III. Reactive Resistance, Not Transcendence
These are fundamentally different states. The former is transcendence; the latter is reactive resistance. Transcendence means one can perceive the power of worldly evaluation without being fundamentally governed by it. Reaction means one is still governed by it, merely adopting an oppositional posture. What appears as intense anti-utilitarian expression is often the reactive stance of the defeated. It establishes no new stable order; it merely harbours resentment against the old one, taking the old order as its reference point and rewriting the object of pursuit into an object of critique.
If I am honest, I must admit that I have likely remained in this reactive state for a long time. I have not reordered life and success. What I have done is hold two conflicting evaluative systems simultaneously – one condemning me for insufficient success, the other consoling me that success is unnecessary. The former derives from the training of reality, the filtering of educational systems, the pricing of industry competition, and the final verdict delivered by that woman; the latter derives from my aspiration that ‘a human should be human’, from my instinctive resistance to alienation, instrumentalisation, and capital logic, and from my genuine experiences of leisure, wandering, and purposelessness during earlier periods of life. The problem is that these two systems remain unintegrated within me; they pull against each other, cancelling each other out, leaving me unable either to fully commit to competition or to live with stability.
Thus emerges an absurd yet accurate scene: I genuinely long for walking, reading, exhibitions, music, bus rides, photography, and flowers – forms of time that are non-utilitarian. Yet the moment I engage in them, another internal judge immediately pronounces: today you have not improved, produced, accumulated, or advanced any clear objective; you are wasting time, you are decaying. On the surface, this appears as value conflict; in essence, it is a conflict of sovereignty. I know what kind of life I desire; I have not granted that life genuine legitimacy. I praise it verbally, yet still allow performance logic to monopolise final judgement. My leisure is merely tolerated as a subordinate process for restoring work capacity, never recognised as life itself. Once detached from the premise of ‘serving better work performance’, it is immediately judged suspicious, inefficient, even guilty.
This indicates that my so-called ‘life first’ has not become my core value. It is merely a defensive concept mobilised at certain moments to counter external pressure. It resembles a wartime slogan rather than a constitution. It appears when I am provoked, compared, or humiliated, providing psychological cover; yet in actual allocation of time and daily decision-making, it quickly recedes, returning legislative authority to efficiency, competition, measurable returns, and future appreciation. In other words, I merely borrow the name of ‘life’ to temporarily resist competitive order; I am not centred on it.
IV. The Hybrid Truth of Non-Utilitarian Life
Yet to conclude here that ‘life first is merely a defence mechanism’ would still be crude. Human reality is rarely a binary between entirely sincere value and entirely false rationalisation. More often it is hybrid: a concept may possess genuine experiential grounding while also serving defensive functions; it may express inner need while masking incapacity; it may be both value judgement and self-protection. I suspect my ‘life first’ belongs to precisely such a hybrid state.
It is not wholly false, because I am indeed not someone capable of endlessly tolerating a fully instrumentalised existence. My need for leisure, aesthetics, reading, and wandering is not fabricated. I have genuinely experienced moments of low-purpose fulfilment – moments unrelated to capital accumulation, performance metrics, or status elevation, yet not empty for that reason. Sitting on a bus across the city, accomplishing nothing worth recording on a résumé, yet feeling, through light, wind, streets, trees, buildings, and faces, that one is not entirely dead – this experience is real. It was not taught to me; I lived it. It proves that I did not invent ‘life’ merely as a product of failure.
But this does not absolve me. Authentic experience does not automatically equal authentic prioritisation. One may genuinely love a certain quality of life, yet elevate it excessively after failure to compensate for what one could not obtain. The real question is this: when life and success are in tension, which am I prepared to place higher? And will this ordering remain stable if my material circumstances improve? If I speak highly of life today due to stagnant income, yet tomorrow, upon obtaining better opportunities, higher pay, and clearer advancement, willingly demote life, then my present philosophical expressions are merely rhetorical products of deprivation. Only if, after improvement of resources, I still preserve inviolable boundaries for leisure, non-utilitarian activity, aesthetics, and inner space, can ‘life first’ possess genuine stability.
This constitutes a brutally cold test: do I oppose the logic that reduces humans to instruments of capital itself, or merely oppose my low position within it? If the former, then even if I ascend in income and status, I will remain vigilant against its encroachment. If the latter, then my current critique is merely resentment. People rarely admit resentment, for it lacks dignity; it is harder to acknowledge than ambition. Yet I must admit that my thought likely contains such elements. I may simply resent the world of winners from the standpoint of the defeated, rather than criticising competition from a standpoint of truth.
This does not render the world of winners correct. The evaluative system composed of capital, platforms, salaries, and status is inherently crude and reductive, excluding complex human experience. But the crudeness of a system does not grant automatic insight to those excluded by it. Many who fail have merely been rejected by the system, not seen through it. Rejection alone does not produce insight. If I cannot distinguish between ‘my critique of this world’ and ‘the resentment triggered by its rejection of me’, then all my philosophical posture risks being merely refined camouflage for emotion.
V. The Collapse of a Flattering Self-Image
Thus the problem converges upon a more embarrassing yet clearer point: what kind of person am I? I once preferred to imagine myself as someone insufficiently successful yet retaining a degree of spiritual independence; someone who had not won much yet had not surrendered to utilitarian logic; someone still capable of responding to literature, philosophy, leisure, and purposeless life. This self-image is not entirely fictitious, but it is evidently selectively edited. It preserves what I am willing to claim, while suppressing what I am not. It highlights my ‘human aspect’ while evading my ‘competitive aspect’; it praises my sensitivity and reflection while concealing vanity, comparison, jealousy, humiliation, and anxiety about worthiness. Thus, while I appear to seek self-knowledge, I have in fact remained within a refined form of self-idealisation.
VI. Two Impulses Without Integration
True self-knowledge requires admitting that I am not unified. I contain at least two equally real impulses. First, I genuinely desire a life not fully instrumentalised – one in which I can read, walk, think, perceive beauty, wander, and maintain non-utilitarian relations with the world. Second, I equally desire a better position in career and worldly competition – higher income, validated ability, relief from lagging behind, and freedom from being judged unworthy in intimate relations. Both are real. The issue is that I have long attempted to let the former cancel the latter, as though firm belief in the value of life could eliminate my desire for victory, dignity, and social valuation.
This approach is doomed to fail. What is suppressed does not disappear; it resurfaces elsewhere. Thus, whenever I try to live, another self accuses me; whenever I compete, this self condemns me as vulgar, utilitarian, alienated. I neither allow myself to pursue worldly success directly, nor permit myself to peacefully enjoy life beyond it. I become a courtroom of internal judgement rather than an acting subject. My contradiction persists because I avoid a simple and undignified fact: I want both, yet have neither paid sufficient cost for either, nor established an order capable of integrating them.
At this point, the question of whether I am ‘naïve’ acquires new meaning. There is nothing naïve in aspiring to life. True naivety lies in believing that articulating a higher value removes the pain of lower status; that reading literature and philosophy elevates one above those concerned with salary and promotion; that imagining oneself ‘not vulgar’ replaces honest examination of one’s desires. A deeper naivety lies in mistaking reluctance to admit ambition for spiritual purity, translating inability to win into voluntary withdrawal, and confusing uncompleted self-integration with achieved maturity.
VII. Time Allocation as the Real Order of Values
If I am to be responsible to myself, I must cease using overly elegant slogans such as ‘life is more important than utility’. This statement may not be false, but it is too smooth – so smooth that it conceals real conflict. It makes one appear noble but guides no concrete decision. The real issue is never abstract importance. It is this: to what extent am I willing to accept higher intensity, reduced leisure, and greater risk in exchange for income and security; whether I can refrain from judging time that produces no output; whether I can bear relative lag when others advance while I preserve life boundaries. These are questions of ordering and cost, not slogans.
And ordering can only be demonstrated through allocation of time. What matters is how one partitions one’s finite life. Claims about value are meaningless. My time is allocated to anxiety, comparison, skill pursuit, and professional unease, and also to fragmented reading, occasional walking, and intermittent aesthetic experience – but the latter has not formed sovereignty; it remains residual. This indicates that I am someone exhausted within competitive order who retains a residual longing for life. This judgement lacks nobility, but is closer to truth than self-praise.
Thus, a more accurate statement may be: I require both a dignified position within reality and a space of life not entirely consumed by it. I do wish to win, but cannot accept becoming entirely mechanised in doing so; I cannot truly be content with poverty, yet know that winning alone does not constitute life. This formulation lacks elegance and manifesto-like quality, but approaches fact. It acknowledges me as shaped by reality while resisting alienation, rather than elevating me into a transcendent subject. I am neither noble nor pure; I have not seen through the world – I am merely wounded within it, yet unwilling to fully submit.
This may be the first truth I must accept.
VIII. A Less Elegant but More Honest Conclusion
The second is harsher: until I admit my genuine desire for worldly success, I will never be able to live calmly. Every attempt at living will be seen by the suppressed competitor as betrayal; every attempt at competition will be judged by the idealised ‘life-self’ as degradation. Only when I admit that I also want to win, fear poverty, and care about status and recognition, can life cease to be a defensive slogan and become life itself. Otherwise, my love of life is always entangled with escape, and my pursuit of success entangled with shame. I remain suspended – failing, theorising, envying, denigrating, desiring, and disguising simultaneously.
This has been my most authentic mental state in recent years: not balance, but repeated tearing. The cause is my refusal to be sufficiently ruthless towards myself. I wish to preserve dignity – to render desire refined, failure justified, stagnation meaningful. Yet true self-critique demands abandoning such rhetorical dignity. I must admit that at times my values are ornaments after failure; my praise of life a compensatory rhetoric; my discussion of literature and philosophy a temporary concealment of impotence, envy, and defeat.
Admitting all this does not ease matters; it removes cheap consolation. Once I can no longer say simply ‘I value life more’, I must confront reality: dissatisfaction with my position, unwillingness to stagnate, pain before others’ progress, and the lingering shadow of ‘you are unworthy’. Simultaneously, I require the useless: reading, wandering, scenery, music, exhibitions, photography, streets, dusk, trees, air – time that cannot be converted into performance, yet proves I remain human. Both must coexist. Only then does the problem return from pseudo-philosophy to life.
And life does not reward elegant conclusions. It demands boundaries, costs, and tolerance of impurity. I may not arrive at any grand statement. I may no longer say ‘life above all’ or ‘success is trivial’. I can only state, more restrained and less dignified: I seek a position where I am not humiliated or displaced; within it, I retain time and experience serving no objective; I no longer disguise ambition as vulgarity, nor life as nobility. This is no philosophical victory. It is a reduction of self-deception.
If a provisional conclusion must be written, it is this: What I loved was the dignity the slogan ‘life first’ once granted me, not the slogan itself. Nor do I merely envy others’ income and position; I envy the state of no longer needing to justify one’s value. The former elevates me above reality; the latter places me beneath it. Thus I remain suspended between them, unable either to admit worldly desire or to properly enjoy non-worldly time.
What must be reconstructed is not a grand declaration, but a more honest definition of self: I still care about success and failure while refusing to let them monopolise meaning. I am a critic wounded within capital logic, not one standing outside it. I am not naturally mature; I can simply no longer conceal mixture, resentment, ambition, vulnerability, and shame beneath beautiful language.
Having said all this, I am at least closer to truth – even if it lacks grace. And that is preferable to mistaking defence for belief, impotence for transcendence, and fragmentation for depth.